主题：孙杨的仲裁报告全文出来了总共78页 -- ErgoSum

共:💬33 🌺105 🌵7 新:

老视野待整

孙杨的仲裁报告全文出来了总共78页

刚才草草看了一下对争议事实的认定。

对于采血过程是这样写的

The Athlete claims that he questioned the documentation shown to him at this early stage, although that is contested. Nevertheless, he was apparently sufficiently satisfied with the documents shown to him, as he signed the Doping Control Form and cooperated in providing two blood samples. These were sealed in glass containers and stored in a storage box.

但之后sy对检测人员资质质疑，一番争执之下，发生了暴力抗检or分离包装的行为。具体是FACTUAL BACKGROUND A. The Collection Attempt中从13到16的部分。

13. In response to these efforts, the DCO sought to warn the Athlete that any removal of the blood samples could be considered as a failure to comply with the sample collection process, and that such action might give rise to serious consequences. Under pressure from the Athlete, the DCO or BCA took the glass containers from the storage box and handed them to the Athlete.

14. When the DCO indicated to the Athlete that no IDTM material could be left behind, the Athlete instructed his entourage to break one of the glass containers with the purpose of extracting the blood sample so that the DCO could take back the broken container but not the blood sample. The glass container containing the blood vessel was destroyed with a hammer by a security guard. The Athlete assisted the security guard by illuminating the blood container with the flashlight of his mobile phone. The blood vessel remained intact, and was retrieved by the Athlete.

检查官告诉sy样品是检查机构财产之后，sy似乎理解为只是外包装而非血样本身？这也许能勉强解释他的动机——把人家拿来的检测包装还给人家嘛。方式则是保安用锤子砸开，sy在旁边用手电照着。血样最后由sy保存，也就是他前几天微博上晒出来那个吧。

15. As a consequence of these events, no blood or urine samples were collected that evening, and none could be made available for analysis. To the Panel’s knowledge, the collected blood vessels remain in the possession of Dr Ba Zhen (although they are no longer eligible to be tested because the chain of custody was broken).

16. Thereafter, in the presence of the DCO, the Athlete destroyed the Doping Control Form that he had previously signed by tearing it up.

所以除了“分离包装”，还发生了撕毁表格或者叫“用强制有形力方式改变纸质文件物理形态”的行为。

链接如下[URL= https://www.tas-cas.org/fileadmin/user_upload/CAS_Award_6148_website.pdf]报告[/URL]

PS：大致看完了全文老实讲有点吃惊。sy的黑点比我想象的还多，居然还有恐吓证人的嫌疑。

有个细节印象深刻：由于对翻译不满（其实是sy方面自己安排的）最后陈词的时候sy找了一个陌生人来帮他，“坐在他的桌子旁担任翻译。他似乎并不认为，这有必要寻求仲裁组的许可，建议他尊重他人的权威或程序的权威。他是世界一流的运动员，拥有令人印象深刻的体育成就，但是规则适用于他，就像适用于所有运动员一样，必须遵守。”

he invited an unknown and unannounced person from the public gallery to join him at his table and act as an impromptu interpreter. He did not seem to deem it necessary to seek the permission of the Panel, or to otherwise act in a manner which suggested that he respected the authority of others, or of established procedures. The Athlete is a world- class athlete, with an impressive list of sporting achievements; he is not, however, above the law or legal process. The rules apply to him as they do to all athletes, and he is required to comply with them.

复孙杨的仲裁报告全文出来了总共78页

家园

老实讲sy现在应该立刻放下身段出来道歉悔改请求原谅

中国人民很善良，不像日本人，谁认错谁倒霉，反而是会念在过去功劳上心软。

这是sy止损的关键时机。不要说什么商业价值，他还年轻人生还很久，完全不应该被这一次错误彻底拖垮。

而还要继续无条件维护他的人，就真是把他放火上烤了。

复孙杨的仲裁报告全文出来了总共78页

家园

特意去看了下那个换翻译的操作

链接在这里视频

看完尴尬癌都要犯了。不得不说，这个细节展示了sy一方对规则的漠视，甚至是一种下意识的习惯（团队缺乏准备还有英语什么的就不吐槽了）。讲到一半临时要求换翻译，至少要先向法庭申请，法庭同意了你再换啊。结果就这么冲上来一个人往旁边一坐。仲裁庭都懵逼了，“你谁啊？” 单就这一点就会给所有仲裁员留下非常不好的印象。

法庭当时已经说，“好的，你来翻吧”，然后发现不行，你没有向我们事先（庭前）申报过有这么个人，那不行，这不符合规定，你不能上来。sy你可以从box里选一个人来。

sy这个案子当时双方在辩什么？辩的就是规则啊。sy你说人家检查官资质不够，拿的文书上没有你的名字，所以你不配合检查。结果你事先也不向法庭报备，当场也不向法庭申请，随便就拉了一个人上来。是对你检查更严肃还是现在的法庭更严肃？怎么当时你要求别人有资质，现在你自己就完全无视资质？那你到底是不是因为“资质”问题而拒检的？

好在当时庭辩已经结束，不然对面律师就这一件事就能把sy整个团队打趴下。

旁边的律师不知道是fina的还是sy的，简直尴尬到不行。要求暂停搞清楚，心里估计已经把这队友骂死了

要不然网上播一半掐直播呢。。。

作为反抗西方虚伪强权的英雄，历史留名是没有问题。

很多国内明星在这个方面都有些傻，只懂得赚钱，不懂得引导建立规则。

孙杨赚得钱也不少了，今后我看是没法从国外游泳方面赚钱了。

不如拿出一部分钱，请人来写一份报告。放在自己微薄里公布。

人家78页，你就搞个780页。看谁多。